payroll and HR software comparison

Payroll and HR software comparison for Canadian employers: find the best fit, then cost it properly

Payroll software is only as good as the Canadian rules it gets right. Compare software types and pricing models, turn illustrative prices into a monthly and three-year budget, and check the 2026 CPP, EI, remittance, T4 and ROE requirements before you sign.

  • Software types and pricing models compared, with no rankings and no invented vendor prices
  • Calculators for monthly cost per employee, renewal and FX uplift, and payback from manual payroll
  • 2026 source deductions, remitter types, T4 and ROE deadlines, vacation pay and Quebec pointers

Start herePayroll Software Monthly Cost Estimator (per employee)

Owner of a small bakery at a back-office table reviewing a printed staff schedule beside a closed laptop

Explore by topic

All guides →

Tools

Payroll and HR software types compared

Software typeHow it is usually pricedOften a good fit forWatch out for
Spreadsheet plus the CRA Payroll Deductions Online Calculator (manual)No subscription; cost is your time, bank transfer fees and any accountant help at year-endVery small employers with one to three salaried staff and simple payHand-entered remittances, T4s and ROEs; easy to miss a due date or a mid-year formula change
Payroll module inside accounting softwareMonthly add-on to the accounting plan, often per employeeSmall employers who already keep their books in that packageThin HR features; check ROE submission, multi-province vacation pay and Quebec support
Standalone payroll SaaS (self-serve)Base fee plus a per-employee monthly price, sometimes per pay run; year-end slips may be extraEmployers with 5–100 staff who want payroll done correctly without a full HR suitePer-run and year-end fees, renewal increases, export of history if you leave
Payroll plus HR suite (HRIS)Per employee per month by tier; time, scheduling, onboarding or performance often sold as modulesGrowing employers who need HR records, self-service, time off and scheduling in one placePaying for modules nobody uses; minimum employee counts; implementation fees

Comparison →

Frequently asked questions

What is the best payroll and HR software for a small business in Canada?

There is no single best product, only the best fit for your headcount, provinces, pay complexity and the person who will run payroll. A five-person salaried team can often use a payroll module or self-serve payroll; a multi-province hourly workforce usually needs time, scheduling and stronger vacation pay rules. Use the selection checklist to find the fit, then cost it over three years.

How much does payroll software cost per employee in Canada?

Most payroll and HR software is priced per employee per month, often with a monthly base fee, and some tools add per-pay-run or year-end slip fees. Prices vary widely by type, tier and contract, so this site uses clearly illustrative ranges only. Run your own numbers in the monthly cost estimator.

What are the 2026 CPP and EI maximums?

For 2026 the CRA lists maximum pensionable earnings of $74,600 with a $3,500 basic exemption and a 5.95% employee and employer CPP rate, for a maximum of $4,230.45 each. CPP2 applies at 4% up to $85,000. EI insurable earnings are capped at $68,900, with an employee rate of 1.63% outside Quebec (1.30% in Quebec). See 2026 source deductions.

When are T4 slips due and do I have to file them electronically?

T4 slips and the T4 Summary are due on the last day of February following the calendar year. If you file more than five slips of a type for a calendar year, the CRA requires you to file them electronically. See T4 slips and electronic filing.

Can I switch payroll software in the middle of the year?

Yes, but the new system needs accurate year-to-date earnings, deductions and CPP and EI amounts for every employee, or the T4s will be wrong. A quarter start, and ideally 1 January, is the cleanest switch date. Read switching payroll providers mid-year.

Is GST/HST charged on payroll software subscriptions?

Generally yes: a software subscription is a taxable supply, and foreign vendors may charge GST/HST under the digital economy rules. A registered business usually recovers that tax as an input tax credit. Provincial sales tax and QST rules also apply in some provinces. See GST/HST and USD pricing.

How long do I have to keep payroll records?

Under section 230 of the Income Tax Act, records generally must be kept for six years from the end of the last tax year they relate to, and Service Canada asks employers to keep ROE-related payroll records for six years. Provincial employment standards laws set their own retention periods. See record retention and employee privacy.

How this site is made

Remit & Roster is an independent information project. Guides are drafted with the help of AI writing tools and checked against official and primary sources before publication; see our Editorial Policy. We are not affiliated with any provider mentioned on the site and do not sell products or services.